The Four Layers
Every assessment runs through four layers, in this order, and the output states where they agree and where they disagree. Disagreement is information, not noise to average away.
1Business Quality
- —Moat type and moat direction.
- —Management capital allocation.
- —Whether the business is explicable in two sentences.
2Valuation
- —Absolute multiples vs. the company's own history and its peers.
- —A reverse read: what growth does the current price already assume, and is that bar conservative or heroic?
3Technical / Timing
- —Primary trend, relative strength vs. sector, volume confirmation.
- —Never overrides Layers 1–2. Can only add or subtract a little; it can never outweigh them.
4Macro / Catalyst
- —Sector cycle position.
- —A named, dateable catalyst — or an explicit statement that none exists.
The Value Check
The Value Check is the headline answer on every stock page: is today's price below, inside or above what the business looks worth?
- 1We value the company four ways, all from its own SEC filings: an earnings multiple (P/E), EV/EBITDA, free-cash-flow yield and a two-stage discounted cash flow (DCF).
- 2Peer multiples come from companies in the same industry. A method that lands far away from the others is left out and the reason is shown.
- 3The methods that remain give a fair-value range (low, middle, high). If fewer than three methods work, we say "not enough data" instead of guessing.
- 4Verdict: Below our estimate if the price is under the range, About right if it is inside, Above our estimate if it is over.
Estimates are re-checked every night. If an estimate looks implausible (for example far below or above the price for a reason the data cannot explain), it is marked "under review" and no verdict is shown until it is fixed. Every change is listed under "What changed" on the stock page.
The Aether Score v1.0
Every covered stock gets an Aether Score from 0 to 100 — a weighted blend of four published layers, computed the same way on every page:
Business Quality (35%). The mean of two sub-scores: Growth trajectory (revenue & EPS YoY, 5Y revenue & EBITDA CAGR) and Financial Health (leverage, liquidity, coverage, profitability/returns). Each input maps to a 0–100 score through fixed threshold tables.
Valuation (30%). A renormalised blend of five multiples — PEG (0.30), P/E TTM (0.25), EV/EBITDA (0.20), P/S (0.15), P/B (0.10) — so a single missing multiple can't swing the score. Missing multiples are dropped and the rest reweighted.
Technical / Timing (20%). Trend from 13-, 26- and 52-week returns plus a beta volatility temper. Held to the guardrail below so it can never override a stretched valuation.
Macro / Catalyst (15%). Two deterministic proxies: a dated catalyst (the next earnings date, scored by proximity) and a cycle-position proxy (indicated dividend yield as a defensiveness signal). Where a layer's inputs are absent its weight redistributes pro-rata across the others.
The guardrail, enforced and visible
- —Timing never overrides fundamentals. If Layer 3 scores above 75 while Layer 2 scores below 50, the total is capped and the derivation shows: "Technical strength doesn't override valuation. Score capped at [n]."
- —An active red flag caps the stance at Weak whatever the score. The v1.0 red-flag set: negative operating cash flow with losses, or net debt / EBITDA above 10×.
- ·The full working — every layer, its weight, every named sub-score and its raw inputs, the guardrail, and a deterministic "what would move this" list — is shown in the derivation panel that opens from any Aether Score on the site. Nothing in it is written by a language model.
- ·Price trend counts for 20% of the score through Layer 3 (Technical / Timing). The guardrail above stops it from ever overriding valuation. Aether’s own prediction-accuracy history is graded separately on the Track Record and never feeds the number.
- ·Scores map to stances at fixed thresholds: below 40 Weak, 40–59 Mixed, 60 and above Strong.
- ·Every score is stamped with the model version that produced it. See the version changelog for every change and whether history was recalculated — it never is, silently.
What the output contains
- ·Aether Score, 0–100
- ·A stance: Strong / Mixed / Weak / Not rated
- ·A transparent scenario calculator — arithmetic you control, not a forecast
- ·Stated invalidation criteria — what would prove this wrong
The four stances
The Scenario Calculator
For forward-looking questions we don't publish a forecast. Every stock page has a scenario calculator instead — transparent arithmetic you control, over a 5-year horizon (switchable to 10):
- ·Inputs default to the company's own history: revenue growth and net margin from the 5-year median, P/E from the 5-year median. Shares outstanding is the current value, held constant.
- ·Bear, base and bull presets: growth and margin use the lowest, median and highest 3-year rolling averages of the past 5 years; P/E uses the 25th, 50th and 75th percentiles. Rolling averages and medians keep a single freak growth year from dominating the defaults.
- ·Guardrails on the presets: growth is capped at 25%/yr for Base and 35%/yr for Bull (20% and 25% on the 10-year horizon) and Bear is floored at -20%/yr; every P/E preset is clamped to 8–40×. When a cap or floor changes a value, the calculator says so under that input. The sliders still go to 50% growth and 60× P/E, so you can test more aggressive assumptions yourself.
- ·A "what's priced in" line shows the yearly revenue growth needed to justify today's price at the base margin and P/E.
- ·The calculation is shown step by step — revenue → profit → profit per share → price — so you can check the math yourself.
- ·Loss-making companies and those with under 3 years of data see "Not enough data for a meaningful scenario" instead of numbers.
- ·It's a calculator, not a forecast. Results depend entirely on the assumptions.
What We Won't Claim
- ·We don't publish a headline accuracy number and won't fabricate one.
- ·Every prediction is logged and graded against what actually happened at the stated horizon.
- ·Those numbers are published on this page — including the bad ones — once the sample is meaningful.
- ·If the model doesn't beat a passive index fund over time, we'll say so.
Known Limitations
- —The model is backward-looking in its inputs. It has no special ability to anticipate novel events.
- —Small and micro-caps are harder to assess — thinner data.
- —Early-stage, pre-revenue and loss-making businesses get no scenario at all — the calculator says "Not enough data" rather than guessing.
- —The world changes faster than any model updates.
Track Record
Every Value Check verdict is logged with its date and price, and graded in public afterwards — misses included. See the full record, with a free CSV download, on the Track Record page.
Until that data is available: treat our assessments as one informed input among several — not as a standalone signal.
Independence
We never take money from the companies we analyse, and no company can pay to change, improve, promote or remove its page on this platform. Our only revenue is subscriptions. A score you read here is the score the model produced — not one a company paid for. See the full statement on our Trust page.
Source Credibility — One Bar for Everything
We score credibility the same way for external news and data sources and for our own predictions. A user comparing our prediction to a news headline should be able to assume both were held to the same visible bar.
- ·Data freshness: How old is the underlying number — a live quote vs. a delayed feed vs. a stale filing.
- ·Source reliability: Is the origin a primary filing, a reputable aggregator, or an unverified secondary report?
- ·Corroboration: Is the claim backed by more than one independent source?
- ·Falsifiability: Is the claim specific enough that you could tell if it were wrong?