Track Record

Our Value Check verdicts as dated calls, graded in public — including the misses. No price targets, ever.

323twelve-month verdicts open·92monthly calls logged·first monthly grades29 Jan 2027·first 12-month grades25 Oct 2027

12-month verdicts

323 open · first grades 25 Oct 2027

The dated Value Check verdicts the homepage counts. Each is graded 12 months after it was made — did the price move toward our estimate? Nothing is gradeable yet.

DateStockVerdictPrice thenEstimate then
13 Nov 2026DJPAbove$48.45—
11 Nov 2026NIAbout right$46.09—
11 Nov 2026EFXAbove$190.19—
8 Nov 2026RYAAYAbove$57.88—
8 Nov 2026PUKAbout right$25.05—
8 Nov 2026METAbout right$102.14—
8 Nov 2026TFCAbout right$49.97—
8 Nov 2026NOCAbove$551.01—
7 Nov 2026SNPSAbove$455.20—
7 Nov 2026EMRAbove$164.40—
7 Nov 2026ELVAbout right$439.28—
7 Nov 2026MCOAbove$507.36—

Monthly 3-month calls

Every valued stock’s month-end verdict, logged monthly and graded against its sector ETF 3 months later. 92 logged · first grades 29 Jan 2027.

DateStockVerdictPrice thenEstimate thenStatus
30 Oct 2026FTNTAbove$136.08Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026NEEAbout right$83.71Not graded
30 Oct 2026MTCHBelow$41.41Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026MSAbove$184.30Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026METABelow$614.99Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026KOAbove$94.08Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026JPMAbout right$336.82Not graded
30 Oct 2026JNJAbove$273.20Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026HCCAbout right$93.92Not graded
30 Oct 2026GSAbout right$894.55Not graded
30 Oct 2026GOOGLAbout right$279.84Not graded
30 Oct 2026GOOGAbout right$278.22Not graded
30 Oct 2026NOWAbout right$105.12Not graded
30 Oct 2026CARGBelow$32.18Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026WFCAbout right$83.49Not graded
30 Oct 2026UPSAbout right$108.66Not graded
30 Oct 2026TXNAbove$300.62Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026TMOAbove$696.87Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026TECKAbove$60.57Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026RIOBelow$83.25Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026QCOMAbout right$164.95Not graded
30 Oct 2026NTRSAbout right$172.92Not graded
30 Oct 2026NTAPAbove$199.95Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026SCHWAbove$89.47Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026SAPAbove$235.02Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026NVOBelow$40.00Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026ALLYAbout right$38.17Not graded
30 Oct 2026ADSKAbout right$249.61Not graded
30 Oct 2026ADPAbout right$293.84Not graded
30 Oct 2026ADIAbove$417.11Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026ACGLBelow$106.36Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026ABCBAbove$82.42Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026STLDAbove$253.53Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026SQMAbove$56.37Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026SLBAbove$53.74Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026MCDBelow$257.96Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026SBUXAbove$105.51Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026RSAbove$404.06Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026PNCAbout right$227.86Not graded
30 Oct 2026PMAbove$208.79Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026PLDAbove$127.98Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026PINSAbove$22.37Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026PGAbout right$161.57Not graded
30 Oct 2026PFEBelow$29.73Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026PEPBelow$137.34Resolves 29 Jan 2027
30 Oct 2026ORCLAbout right$130.67Not graded
30 Oct 2026AFGAbout right$153.87Not graded
30 Oct 2026AMTAbout right$187.78Not graded
30 Oct 2026AMPAbout right$490.83Not graded
30 Oct 2026AMGNAbout right$466.01Not graded

Stocks without a confirmed month-end closing price are excluded from the monthly calls, so the count for a given month may be lower than the valued universe. Calls already recorded stay unchanged when an estimate is later revised.

Hit rate by verdict

Each verdict is graded 3 months after it was made — did the rule hold? Below = the stock beats its sector ETF; Above = the stock lags it. “Too few to judge” under 30 graded calls.

Below our estimate
No calls graded yet0/0 held
Above our estimate
No calls graded yet0/0 held
About right
Not graded38 calls

Calls we got wrong

Every miss is listed — never collapsed. The rule did not hold over the 3-month window.

No misses yet. No call has been graded (the first grades are due 29 Jan 2027).

Download the full record

Both record types, with a record_type column. Free, no account.

Weekly Top 3 vs VOO, VTI, QQQ

Cumulative return since the first Monday’s open, rebased to 100. The three stocks we picked each week against the broad market.

9 Nov9 Nov9899100101102

Top 3

0%

VOO

+1.5%

VTI

+1.4%

QQQ

+2.4%

Append-only. Monthly calls can’t be edited or deleted. The grading job fills the outcome fields once, 3 months after each call. 12-month verdicts are the live current view (one per stock) and are graded in place after 12 months.

How the Value Check works →

This is research and monitoring, not a trade instruction or a recommendation. Aether never places trades or moves money.

Create a free account to see every check on every stock. Create a free account